Dorothy wants the students to put on a theater performance. Reluctantly the students agree, and go to the library to find a suitable play. They find a dusty old piece with a character for each student. They start to practice immediately. The only problem is that the play doesn’t have an ending, and one of the characters played by Victoria has to write the ending of the play. What the children don’t know is that this is a banned play and soon the students become possessed by the characters in the play. Elsa turns out to be a vengeful witch whose mission is to take over Creepschool. Dorothy has to get Victoria to write a new ending where the children are released from the spell.